The ray of light that never lands: non-supernatural views of rebirth

Jun 1st, 2011 | By | Category: Philosphical thoughts

The notions of rebirth and reincarnation are crucial to the Buddhist worldview : ‘rebirth’ can be considered as a crude English translation of ‘Punarbhava’ ( re-emergence of self, Sanskrit). Those amongst us who seek scientific explanations for non-scientific concepts might find it difficult to frame any testable or falsifiable hypothesis in the support or the denial of the notion of the Buddhist philosophical self and its re-emergence. However, even though a concept cannot be framed in scientific terms, we still may employ scientific reasoning to study it.

Although we can define concepts like life and death with degrees of scientific objectivity, such definitions are essentially useless in a spiritual context that combines philosophical and rational understanding. It is when we apply these concepts to our own existence that its philosophical significance emerges, and to a large extent the same applies to the concept of rebirth. This perhaps explains why nearly a quarter of all Western Europeans stated that they believe in reincarnation in the oft quoted European values survey(1) in 2006. Despite the fact that reincarnation does not exist in either Christianity or science, the two traditional sources that have generated philosophical viewpoints in western Europe. Figures are higher in the Nordic countries and eastern Europe, and in addition, another 20 to 25% or so indicated that they did not know and maintained an open mind on the issue.

Despite scientific debates on the significance of findings suggestive of evidence of reincarnation (e.g. Dr. Ian Stevenson and Jim B. Tucker’s work at the University of Virginia medical school) (2), alternative possibilities for holding completely non-supernatural views can emerge from the sociological point of view. For instance,  viewing life on Earth as an interconnected web can also produce significant insights into the life-and-death of individual entities as local phenomena within a much broader web of interconnected living beings. In this sense, reincarnation can be thought of as a process by which the broader process called life renews itself as it regenerates its worn out parts. Ancient Hindu and Buddhist philosophy often talk of models of cyclical processes applicable to various phenomena, which perhaps loosely fits with this line of reasoning.

The other possibility is to view consciousness itself as a globally participative process, in which individuals contribute with their thoughts and actions, creating ripples and effects that are perhaps referred to as Karma within Buddhism. Perhaps, if consciousness can be considered as the essence of our existence, then reincarnation simply implies the biological emergence of an entity capable of independent thoughts which can affect the process of consciousness itself effected through various mechanisms that can be referred to as Karma. In this sense our individual lives and deaths are perhaps insignificant events in the bigger scheme of consciousness at the supra-species level In terms of biological hierarchy.

As the horizons of science expand, perhaps the limits of spiritual reasoning will, too.


(1) Popular psychology, belief in life after death and reincarnation in the Nordic countries, Westernand Eastern Europe. Nordic Psychology, 2006, 58 (2) 171-180


Correspondence :

The Editor
Metta-Physics Magazine
Suite 34
67-68 Hatton Garden
London EC1N 8JY
United Kingdom

Tags: , , , ,

17 Comments to “The ray of light that never lands: non-supernatural views of rebirth”

  1. […] Spirituality and Science The ray of light that never lands: non-supernatural views of rebirth, In a demonstration of how science helps to extend spirituality, two examples of non-supernatural views of rebirth and reincarnation are shown in this article. […]

  2. […] in the support or the denial of the notion of the Buddhist philosophical self and its re-emergence. Read More…What if the ‘God Particle’ has really been found ?The hypothetical massive Higgs boson particle […]

  3. […] Spirituality and Science The ray of light that never lands: non-supernatural views of rebirth, In a demonstration of how science helps to extend spirituality, two examples of non-supernatural views of rebirth and reincarnation are shown in this article. […]

  4. So to take up a lengthy history I needed obtained together with my hubby after i was 15 as
    well as this individual had been twenty one, indeed I’m sure
    that it ended up being completely wrong inside age impression but he / she had been the 1st dude to exhibit everyone legitimate awareness as well as really like various other
    then your folks whom simply wished to rest when camping.

    So allows get back to know, Internet marketing 21 and have absolutely a new 5 months old infant at this point in addition to my better half couldnt
    you have to be tired of you until in case he or she want intercourse with me at night.

    I had created your child by way of Csection and the very first thing he do whenever this individual obtained property
    was take a seat as well as participate in dissertation publishing dwell definitely
    not make sure we ended up okay simply no he / she desired to enjoy dissertation assistance
    And after this he / she just usually spends many their occasion cigarettes weed and also getting together with their pals and meanwhile internet marketing being a single mama the item appears like.

    Ever impression in which child came to be We’ve carried out every thing to be certain she’s balanced and also delighted possesses almost everything
    she requires, I’ve got got a job along with received a couple of
    additional employment delivers along with he has never lifted a hand
    to try and do something that can help all of us. He is twenty-five and
    also I am just usually the one publishing work apps with regard to your pet, and also
    It’s my job to get each of our complete relationship then when this individual decided not to employ a task
    I did along with at sixteen We was working and also paying for his or her fuel as well as tobacco although they seated about along
    with intravenous done that each and every time they ended up being fired or laid off.

    Not to mention when he / she retains the baby the girl whines in addition to they won’t attempt to calm the woman’s they only palms her returning to myself and yes it smashes my cardiovascular simply because they overlooked out on bonding together with your
    ex and anyone all around you could see the item, our mums often wanting
    to know us how you are carrying out in addition to plugs just how the lady can tell i’m
    unhappy and that the newborn could sense that while i find unhappy or even anxious as well as We tend not to need to do in which.

    the particular more painful element can be We have zero close friend to talk to and also he retains
    indicating he’s going to educate everyone to drive and not may in addition to im starting to feel like he / she can it
    to help keep me stuck in addition to isolated, he are not able to determine
    exactly why i will be consequently disappointed dissertation writing but anytime
    We seek to talk with your ex over it their response incorporate
    yep, acceptable, certain, as well as definitely the I’m going
    to change… I am unable to rely the quantity of instances
    he’s got explained I will alter as well as performed good for daily and
    then returned in order to his / her shitty means.
    My spouse and i dont understand what internet marketing requesting and also I will be
    undecided precisely what in addition to convey I can continue for
    hours about how little interest he displays in me and the infant but it really might
    you have to be excessive text writing dissertaton
    Since enquired beneath We are basically at
    present experiencing my mom and dad with all the infant in addition to
    he or she existence with his father although they doesn’t have actually
    still left my mother and father but on the other hand I have asked as
    well as my personal mother and father maintain wondering how
    much time he strategies in keeping yourself.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.